16+

Top Tesla Model Y alternatives: six electric SUVs compared

© A. Krivonosov
Explore six compelling Tesla Model Y alternatives: Mach-E, Ioniq 5, ID.4, Ariya, EV6 and Audi e-tron. We compare range, comfort and tech to help you choose.
Michael Powers, Editor

Tesla Model Y is the world’s best-selling electric SUV on today’s global market, coming close to the gasoline-powered Honda CR-V in overall sales. The draw is obvious: according to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, the entry Model Y can travel 420 km on a single charge.

Even so, a number of rival electric crossovers make a strong case of their own. Below are six that can confidently stand alongside the Model Y.

Ford Mustang Mach-E

This sporty crossover turns heads with its distinctive performance-inspired look and a contemporary cabin. Its range trails the Model Y slightly at about 402 km, yet it fights back with a comfortable interior and responsive, agreeable handling that makes everyday driving feel effortless.

Hyundai Ioniq 5

The Korean brand leans into a bold design concept inside and out, and car enthusiasts have responded warmly. It’s packed with useful features and looks fresh and modern. Still, despite the generous equipment list, real-world range comes in a bit lower than the class leaders, which can temper its appeal for some buyers.

Volkswagen ID.4

Volkswagen’s electric ID.4 serves up generous interior space and a notably quiet ride. It’s loaded with advanced safety and comfort technology, but owners often point to frustrations with the infotainment interface, which can be a recurring source of irritation.

Nissan Ariya

This Japanese EV stands out for its smooth ride and a suite of modern technologies that make driving easier. The catch is that the standard version offers a markedly shorter range than many competitors, a significant drawback for drivers who prioritize distance between charges.

Kia EV6

Kia’s EV6 delivers aggressive styling and strong acceleration, an enticing combination for those who enjoy a bit of pace. While cabin materials and overall comfort could be better, its power and lively character help it cut through a crowded field.

Audi e-tron

Audi’s premium e-tron showcases high-grade interior materials and meticulous attention to detail. The flip side is that it lags behind rivals in cutting-edge tech and offers a notably limited driving range, prompting more frequent stops at the plug.